Private 5 year vow renewal at Disney?

You know what? Do what makes you happy. Who cares what other people think?

And talk to Robyn because she and Simon did a 5-year vow renewal.

Yeah we were at just 5 years, we did it cause we wanted to, stuff what others think, it's our marriage we too had dramas in the lead up to the wedding which is one of the reasons we decided to do it. Do what makes you happy

Do what makes both of you happy!

My wife and I did it every five years; Vegas, Disney, etc. Mainly because I can't believe she still wants to be married to me, beast that I am.

I agree with everyone else...do what makes you happy. As for the rules, I don't think there are any rules against stopping at a favorite spot for a few minutes, whether it be at a resort or in a park, and professing your love for each other. If it's just the two of you, nobody else will know what's actually going on.

Robyn and Simon did theirs in their room. Didn't you, Robyn? On the balcony at which resort?

We did it in the Rose Garden at MK- the pixies at Gifts of a Lifetime did a whole thing for us. It was cute.

Then absolutely do whatever makes you happy. I'm personally not a big fan of vow renewals (much in the way that I'm not a fan of "sprinkles" AKA: second baby showers), but mostly because of the guest situation. I think some people use it as a way to get gifts or as a way to try and save something that's broken. I personally would probably never attend one because I don't really believe in them as an event, but if it's something personal for you and your DH then all the power to ya! So many fun romantic things you could do too.
We recently did the horse drawn carriage ride at PORS and thought it would be really romantic if it was after dark. Also, that personal dinner that Robyn and Sy did looked pretty nice.

They just don't want groups of people grand-standing and holding their own events. If it's just you two (actually private) just do it. Prop up a camera on a mini-tripod. Check out this place (the little fountain outside Italy):
http://www.magicaldayweddings.com/epcot-italy-isola-2

Go for it! I see a vow renewal as not really being about how much time has passed, but about recommitting to each other going forward.

Agree with everyone else, do what is right for you guys. But of course, take lots of pictures for all of us

It was never allowed by Disney but I think they used to look the other way- maybe now they cracked down on it?

I contacted GOL and we came up with a plan. First I gave them our life story. They Disnified our life and wrote Disneyesque vows for us.

They gave me the rendevous point in advance and here is how it went: I took my wife on IASW, right at the end of the ride, a woman sitting behind us hands my wife a scroll and disappears. We get off the ride and read it; its our life story part one- from growing up till when we met. With our parents, family members, our neighborhoods, etc. My wife is freaking out already crying.

Next we're waiting on line for either Snow White or Peter Pan and another woman shows up with another scroll. This one has our life story part two, with our royal marriage, our castle and the birth of our princesses. My wife is crying like a sieve now and my lower lip is trembling a bit as well. We are instructed to proceed to the Rose Garden.

In the Rose Garden we are presented with the final part of our story; the growth of the princesses, royal marriages, grandchildren, etc. Then the Pixies did a very nice vow renewal.

They did the whole thing very nicely. It was cute, funny, touching and with a Disney touch which was fitting in the Magic Kingdom, our happy place.

Awwww you old romantic you!

SUPER adorable, Colonel!