Riding by on the monorail I was struck by all of the people who scheduled their dream wedding with FTW @ the wedding pavilion having to deal with the construction. I agree I wouldn't pay full price in general but to the point of the question: Absolutely not. It is disney's responsibility to provide a magical experience to their guests. They shut down the gym and spa between GF and Poly for the new construction - if you want to go to the gym you need to hop a monorail to the Contemporary. On it's face that isn't a big deal until they were one-up'd by the people managing the yacht & beach club. The gym @ the Yacht & Beach was actually move over to the Solarium in the Beach Club which was a much better choice than doing nothing and telling everyone they needed to head over to The Boardwalk.
The point being: Disney is magical and management needs to provide it regardless. If there is a decision to shut down a pool then something needs to be done to give the guest that missing value. If you are staying at the beach club and stormalong bay is closed: That is a significant reduction in value for staying at the beach club. If the pools and market are closed at the GF then some sort of remuneration needs to be provided for that loos of value and magic. To assume that we, the customer, are staying at these Deluxe resorts "just cuz" is whacky. If there is something closed, planned eyesores or other value-reducing and avoidable events occurring then that needs to be reflecting in the stay. Be it a discount, tickets, meal vouchers, whatever. they chose to expand DVC @ GF and caused the issue voluntarily. They know this is an issue which is why they put facades up ALL OVER the place when they are doing maintenance in the parks. It allows you to see the rabbit in the hat before you are supposed to or the handkerchief sticking out of the sleeve: The magic is gone, especially if you are paying $500-$1000 a night to stay there.