I'm not sure what reviews you've read or seen... but I seem to recall a nice comparison by one of the "Disney Vloggers" on youtube.
If you search "trying new restaurants at disney springs" I think you will probably turn up the video - If I recall correctly, the vlogger does a comparison of the Edison, the hideaway, and Maria & Enzo's, and of course videos his meal and maria & enzos.
(and i double checked ... and that particular video starts the restaurant review about 7 minutes in ... they do some other disney springs stuff beforehand)
There are also several videos on youtube for these restaurants... though I can't really speak to them or their recommendations as I only recall watching this particular video.
Hope you find this helpful... and good luck.