One long trip vs. two ore more short trips: the ultimate debate

Login to post comments
21 posts / 0 new
SpaceAce's picture
Offline
Joined: 07/06/2008
Posts: 2532
One long trip vs. two ore more short trips: the ultimate debate

I've definitely gone back and forth on this over the years and am wondering what others' pro/con lists look like.

The long trip allows for more down time/relaxation as well as paying for only one roundtrip flight vs. two or more.

But those short trips mean you're always looking forward to a Disney trip, and you can "get your fix" in only a few days at Disney World, as long as you know you're coming back soon...

Anyone else come to a definitive decision on this? We're debating yet again this year...

__________________

[url=http://www.wdwforgrownups.com/forum/'http://www.mickeypath.com/']

[/url]

2010 Beach Club Resort
2005 Port Orleans Riverside
2006 Animal Kingdom Lodge
2007 Wilderness Lodge
2008 Animal Kingdom Lodge
2009 CBR/Polynesian

MouseTraveler's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/15/2009
Posts: 919

We used to go and spend a week at a time and enjoyed it immensely.

Now, it seems to take less time to see our favorite things and I don't feel we need as much time. Our last couple of trips have been 4 or 5 days and I really like that. I'd much rather do those more often.

Last summer we spent four nights at OKW, then went to the REAL Key West for four nights. For the most part, I expect thats the way we'll do it in the future.

__________________

Visit our website (work in progress) http://www.mousetraveler.tv
Visit our blog (will NEVER be finished)
http://www.mousetraveler.tv/blog
On Twitter as 'MouseTraveler' and 'BigBlueMan'

bali's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/20/2008
Posts: 3444

I really do enjoy taking several small trips. I'm the type of person who wants to have my next Disney trip booked before I leave the hotel on the current Disney trip, and the only way I can afford that kind of behavior is to do a bunch of little trips. Plus, it's easy to get more time off of work if you go over long weekends several times a year instead of using up all of your vacation days over a couple of weeks.

__________________


May 2008 CSR mickey

SoloFriendly's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/18/2008
Posts: 556

I guess it depends on how often you can--or want to--travel to WDW. If you're the kind of person who will travel to WDW every year and/or if WDW is the only place you ever vacation, then I think you can afford to take more frequent, shorter trips. You've already done everything there is to do there, so you know what you like and what you don't like, and you can afford to skip some things sometimes.

It might also depend on what or who you're leaving behind. If you've got kids and you're leaving them at home with someone else, it might be hard to stay longer than a few days. Same if you're going without your spouse. Or if you have a job or business that you can't leave for very long.

However, if you don't get there very often, you'll want to maximize your experience, and so I think you want your trip to be longer. Or at least, that's how I feel about it. I have only been there once, and it had to be a short trip by necessity: 4 nights and 3 days. Because I'd never been there before, I wanted to cram in as much as possible, and the result was that I visited 4 parks plus downtown disney in that time period and was thoroughly exhausted at the end of the trip. I will never be the kind of person who only vacations at WDW or goes there every year. There are too many other places I want to see.

My next trip in May will be 7 nights and 8 days. That will give me plenty of time to do everything, and also have some downtime to relax. There's nothing worse than coming home from my vacation so tired that I feel like I need another vacation to recover from it. And yet, that is so often the case with me. I've never taken such a long vacation alone, so I'm excited to see if spending a week there takes care of that problem, or if I am incapable of relaxing on a vacation and will just spend 8 days running myself ragged instead of 3. I probably need to build in nap times every day, like a little kid. laugh

__________________

Gray
SoloFriendly.com

MouseTraveler's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/15/2009
Posts: 919

bali wrote:
I'm the type of person who wants to have my next Disney trip booked before I leave the hotel on the current Disney trip, .

I'm with you there! Back in the old days, when there was only the Poly, Contemporary & (then known as) the Golf Resort, I used to come home from a trip and immediately make reservations for the next trip. Back then you had to make them up to a year in advance anyway.

I always like having that date in the back of my mind, knowing I could put it on a calendar and count it down!

__________________

Visit our website (work in progress) http://www.mousetraveler.tv
Visit our blog (will NEVER be finished)
http://www.mousetraveler.tv/blog
On Twitter as 'MouseTraveler' and 'BigBlueMan'

Brad's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/05/2008
Posts: 4357

SoloFriendly wrote:

My next trip in May will
be 7 nights and 8 days. That will give me plenty of time to do
everything, and also have some downtime to relax.

That's always been a huge plus of WDW. It's less stressful in several ways:

1.)
You don't stress about "finding your way around" and things like
that. Even if you're a neophyte, you can find things pretty
easily. (Except when you're driving)

2.) You don't stress about having to see everything. If you miss something, it's not like you missed the Louvre.

Probably the most likely cause of stress is other guests, as Jim points out in the Bad Experiences page.

Annie's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/20/2008
Posts: 1610

SoloFriendly wrote:
You've already done everything there is to do there, so you know what you like and what you don't like, and you can afford to skip some things sometimes.

____________________________________________________________

... I probably need to build in nap times every day, like a little kid. laugh



Such good points, SF. If you're at WDW several times a year, you just don't need to ride Pirates of the Caribbean every single time (for example...). Plus, there are so many other things to do and see at WDW that you're able to make substitutions when you know you'll be back soon.

And, yep, I build naps in just about every day. I like to be at the parks bright and early, and then take advantage of evening parties/EMH when I can, so my typical day does include a nap pretty much every afternoon. It's the only way I can stay "magical." eek laugh

Also, your point about who and what you're leaving behind (kids, spouse, pets, work, home business, etc.) is a really important one. DH and I go to Disney World together, but we've never been comfortable leaving our pets for very long (especially when they get older).

wdwfan's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/26/2008
Posts: 43

Personally, I like to take several shorter trips versus one long one. Like you said, when you get back home you're always anticipating your next visit. If you only go for one long trip per year, it's a LONG stretch between visits. If you take two or three short trips it may cost more but I find you're much happier all year long Smile.

__________________

Steve - Disney Vacation Planner
Visit My Blog at http://wdwfan.wordpress.com

cdub's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/20/2008
Posts: 3220

Can I have a lot of long trips?!? No? Dang...

SpaceAce's picture
Offline
Joined: 07/06/2008
Posts: 2532

wdwfan wrote:
Personally, I like to take several shorter trips versus one long one. Like you said, when you get back home you're always anticipating your next visit. If you only go for one long trip per year, it's a LONG stretch between visits. If you take two or three short trips it may cost more but I find you're much happier all year long Smile.


I think that's probably true--those of us who really do enjoy the anticipation of the trip and get a genuine "happy dose" when we're there might very well benefit from several short trips instead of one long one. It's like weight loss--you're not supposed to deprive yourself! laugh

__________________

[url=http://www.wdwforgrownups.com/forum/'http://www.mickeypath.com/']

[/url]

2010 Beach Club Resort
2005 Port Orleans Riverside
2006 Animal Kingdom Lodge
2007 Wilderness Lodge
2008 Animal Kingdom Lodge
2009 CBR/Polynesian

SoloFriendly's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/18/2008
Posts: 556

Quote:
Also, your point about who and what you're leaving behind (kids,
spouse, pets, work, home business, etc.) is a really important one. DH
and I go to Disney World together, but we've never been comfortable
leaving our pets for very long (especially when they get older).

Pets. Yeah. That was why my last trip was so short. My cat was elderly, and I just didn't feel comfortable leaving her alone for too long. She was really attached to me (and vice versa) and I knew she'd be freaked out that I wasn't home at night. She has since passed on, so I no longer have to worry about anyone back home.

__________________

Gray
SoloFriendly.com

cdub's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/20/2008
Posts: 3220

I always like the longer trips. I love the feeling of when you first get there and know you're not leaving for quite a while. I think the only time I went for a brief trip, we called and tried to stay longer and EVERY resort was sold out. (Or so we were told)

MouseTraveler's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/15/2009
Posts: 919

Since this thread went up, I've thought about this a LOT. Having done Disney as long as I have and seen as much as I have, I've got to go with the shorter trips. I remember that terrible dread after being there a week of knowing you're going home.
Now, after four or five days and having done everything I want to do, I'm more appreciative of having been able to do it.
Its probably a combination of being used to the experience, as well as knowing with the shorter trips it won't be that long until we go back.
Having Southwest Airlines (and traditionally cheap airfare) out of Nashville has probably helpe too!

__________________

Visit our website (work in progress) http://www.mousetraveler.tv
Visit our blog (will NEVER be finished)
http://www.mousetraveler.tv/blog
On Twitter as 'MouseTraveler' and 'BigBlueMan'

bali's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/20/2008
Posts: 3444

MouseTraveler wrote:

Having Southwest Airlines (and traditionally cheap airfare) out of Nashville has probably helpe too!


Absolutely! I don't know what I'd do if I had to deal with no direct flights to Orlando!

And those short trips are great when you just need a little relaxation break. Knowing that you're coming back sooner rather than later makes it easier to leave (and also make it feel like work is just "what you do between Disney trips") mickey

__________________


May 2008 CSR mickey

Brad's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/05/2008
Posts: 4357

SWA is the best. You can make plans at the last minute and not be penalized. Rates are generally pretty reasonable even at the last minute.

MouseTraveler's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/15/2009
Posts: 919

Brad wrote:
SWA is the best. You can make plans at the last minute and not be penalized. Rates are generally pretty reasonable even at the last minute.

Ahhh.. and in the good old days, when people just started buying tickets on the internet, you could get a free ticket with every FOUR purchased on the net. I don't guess I bought a ticket for my wife for years.

__________________

Visit our website (work in progress) http://www.mousetraveler.tv
Visit our blog (will NEVER be finished)
http://www.mousetraveler.tv/blog
On Twitter as 'MouseTraveler' and 'BigBlueMan'

Annie's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/20/2008
Posts: 1610

I'm waiting for the days when no frills airlines in the US are as cheap and easy as they are in Britain and Europe. Easyjet is cheaper and easier than the bus!

cdub's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/20/2008
Posts: 3220

I've jaunted all over the place on Southwest. There' s a reason why they are the only airline making money. So much better of a business model. Just the fact that they use the small airports in cities makes it SO much easier to be on-time.

Brad's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/05/2008
Posts: 4357

MouseTraveler wrote:
Brad wrote:
SWA is the best. You can make plans at the last minute and not be penalized. Rates are generally pretty reasonable even at the last minute.

Ahhh.. and in the good old days, when people just started buying tickets on the internet, you could get a free ticket with every FOUR purchased on the net. I don't guess I bought a ticket for my wife for years.


Yeah Southwest's "Raipd Rewards" program is probably it's least compelling feature. I fly AA a ton and having status on there is really nice, while SWAs "Buy 10 Get One Free" is not nearly as nice. That being said, Southwest is still great.

MouseTraveler's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/15/2009
Posts: 919

Brad wrote:

Yeah Southwest's "Raipd Rewards" program is probably it's least compelling feature. I fly AA a ton and having status on there is really nice, while SWAs "Buy 10 Get One Free" is not nearly as nice. That being said, Southwest is still great.



And they've modified it so that they black out dates now. They used to allow you to take any seat, any time. Not any more.

And as much as I enjoy them, there ARE subtle changes in the past few years. They used to be a lot more fun, and now it seems more like 'business as usual'. Oh well, gone are the "hot pants days" of the early 70's! eek

__________________

Visit our website (work in progress) http://www.mousetraveler.tv
Visit our blog (will NEVER be finished)
http://www.mousetraveler.tv/blog
On Twitter as 'MouseTraveler' and 'BigBlueMan'

bali's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/20/2008
Posts: 3444

MouseTraveler wrote:
Oh well, gone are the "hot pants days" of the early 70's! eek


eek laugh

__________________


May 2008 CSR mickey